Did well tonight. First game back and out of position and just the one error. Not tested under the high ball but that's not his fault. He can be very pleased with his work tonight.

Your post got the response it deserved. I don't need to back it up, but if you have a copy of last years KC derby it will speak for me.

That's the long and the short of it. Even those who don't rate Hall think he is often dangerous in attack.

I thought he had a decent game tonight, he has had a loss of confidence of late and I do not think he has always had a fair rub of the green.

He is going, but he is not heading East as many believe

Perhaps his new coach will bring the best out of him as clearly ours can't or does not want to

Maybe he already has.

Haven't touched the cider in quite a while now thanks.

But what I have done is played the game at a decent amateur level in the past, as well as officiating at 1st team level

I've also watched the game for the best part of 50 years. I've seen what real backs are, not 2nd rows who can't make the weight.

This club, from when Hall was first blamed for a defeat at London Broncos (for failing to kick goals), seem to have systemically tried to undermine his confidence.

Know-nowt, never-done-nowt fools like you seem happy to perpetuate that situation

Carn't the same be said of Tansey though ? Could be great one minute and totally inept the next.

It does seem hard for people to grasp that he may actually not progress.

He's 24? Must of had nearly 60-70 games?

Indeed he did well. That is what is so frustrating about him - there is some talent there its not as though he's a total no hoper. However the decision has been made to get rid and on the balance of probabilities you can't argue with it.

Deary me. Yes, you're right. Everyone's out to get Craig Hall. It's nothing to do with his own inadequacies, the club just decided, for no good reason, to try and turn a brilliant player into a below average one. You might not have touched the cider for a while, but it's clearly left its mark.

Take your life story and shove it up your Ar$e.
He's e.

I can relate to that.

I've said many times that I'm not convinced about Tansey as a full back, but I'd rather see him there than Hall any day of the week.

And you call me an idiot?

Get back under your stone lad, you're not fit to debate with men

I know. This ridiculous notion that the club have somehow decided to turn him into a poor player - what could they possibly have to gain from such a decision?