I'd say 20 penalties each..

Again , I'd go for that idea but can you see a rookie ref stopping the game and telling Ganson , Silverwood there's been an infringement . The linesman aren't giving enough assistance to the refs imo .

havnt seen the play for the saints penalty in the dying minutes but i thought once you have made the decision to tap and play the ball you had to yet halibut allowed saints to go for goal well after that decision was made!

as for the result, are we the first team to take points off saints, (apart from wiggan) since simmons left?

I can imagine it now, the Magic Weekend 2013, live on SKY, final game of the weekend...Ganson reaches to his pocket, raises the Red Card and sends Alibert off!

Pretty much as I see things as well.

Cannot believe we battered them so long and did not get the win.
Hate to say this but Rovers would have scored 50 given that posession.
Shows where we need to address.
Always been a big fan of Horne but poor today and Manu was not good at all.

I'm also curious why we didn't get a penalty for offside when Seymours kick hit Wellens 3 metres in goal then bounced out and Perry picked it up and threw it out. Alibert consulted the in-goal judge then pointed at the cross bar and gave a drop out. Baffling!


You can't be offside in your own in goal area

looke like it hit the cross bar from where we were sat, so was right decision imo

Same here. And I thought it was Lomax going for it, not Wellens.

Agreed.

I also thought he got it right when Westy was obstructing the runners for the kick, a really stupid play there, since they'd not threatened from a kick before that.

I thought we got lucky when Crooks tackled Swift into touch, Swift's ball carrying arm clearly hit the ground before Crooks put him in touch, and should have been a penalty to Saints, before he changed it to a penalty to us. But then we were unlucky with the decision to give the forward pass to Briscoe, so swings and roundabouts really.

didnt see anything wrong with crooks' tackle on the saints player, he hadnt stopped moving so was entitled to drag him into touch, was right in front of us, it was wilkin spitting his dummy out and saints players carrying on mouthing off at alibert that cost them the penalty

It speaks volumes about the quality of this current Hull side, or rather lack of, when you can't even beat the worst Saints side since Super League started.

I thought we already have earlier in the season?

How do Warrington do against Saints last time they played?

I smell a troll, a pretty thick one as well.

You can change your mind from a tap to go for goal, however if you decide to go for goal you cannot change your mind to tap.

harsh call on Manu for an accidental off side at the end. Hull aren't a top 4 side just yet and would welcome abut of luck going into run in to the playoffs to give us.