He's not as bad as Motu

You mean the ball steal....got a clear view of it...was reefed out....but you may not have got a good view on the telly.

I think that justifies MY point right???

I assume that your point was that people were blaming Horne for the loss. Nobody has. So no.

At the time the thread was started he'd made two bad defensive mistakes leading to Leeds tries.

Recently Kosh, I've been really surprised at how much I've agreed with you. It's almost like becoming a mod has given you a neutral, rational opinion. However, if you are one of those prepared to finger point at one player for this loss, I am clearly mistaken. I could not name more than two of our players tonight that didn't make terrible decisions in attack OR defence.

He made 3 mistakes.......got caught out big style....Thack's WAS a ball steal.

I agree on both counts. At the time of my post Sky hadn't shown the replay. In my defence, Thacks does have previous dropping the ball in our 25.

I most certainly am not blaming any one player for our loss. IMO it's very, very rare that such a thing can be justified. I was merely pointing out that the thread was started immediately after Leeds second try when Horne had been caught out defensively on both occasions. He could hardly be blamed for a loss that hadn't even happened at that point, could he?

6 days ago he was taken apart by a big, mobile, pacey Centre so understandably we thought we would give him another go

You could drive round Graeme Horne in one of the pensioners scooters

G Horne, Thorman and Radford were predictably rubbish. I appreciate he has few options to replace them with, but i would rather see some youngster from the academy given a go than those plodders.

Thats why he willl be at Fev next year