Agree with Jake, those two crushers should be pens at least and Swift knocks on.

Can't fault the effort, but a really poor first half and knights stupid stupid tackle cost us two points.


He stays on we win that IMO.


Cartwright has to sort out our discipline as bad as last year.

Looked a shadow of the team from beginning of season

Our players did us not the ref.

Also I don't think Cartwright gets his subs right, why leave Aydin off until the 68th minute, down a man, players tired, use your subs.

Luke Robinson acting like he's just watched a prime Penrith team playing. Has he forgot they were against 12 men for a full half

Need our second rowers back ...Just looked off all over the park ...

Just stupid from us. We didn't learn anything from last few games, errors leading to penalties again . 

Efforts still there, lacking in brains.

Players playing constantly out of position hasn't helped either.


Big test the next three games, could define our season.

Fair play to them for sticking at it throughout the second forty, but we got what we deserved over the course of the whole match.


The only reason we were still in with a shout going into the last five minutes was due to how poor Huddersfield are, no wonder they've opened with nought from nine! Makes this defeat all the more galling really.


I had an uneasy feeling about this one all week, intensified when Wilkin tipped us to win by sixteen, I knew we were done for at that point!! Trust us to mess up this one, typical us!!


Before the game Cartwright said that the problem with playing close score games is that sometime they will fall your way and sometimes it will go against you, think he was tempting fate with that one!


We've a week off now. The squad need to reset and go again. We need to pick up the momentum again or the season could, potentially, start to slide backwards. We're still ahead of the curve but a couple of further defeats will have a deflating effect on all. Fingers crossed this is just a temporary dip in fortune.

Let's be honest that was poor. Effort there second half but we looked tired and slow ....But then gifting them the ball with 12 men.....So disappointed today

Also unbelievable tackle for Flaggan on Cust, we score there we win the game.


He is going to be an unbelievable player.

I do think no second rowers is penalising us, really need some soecialist players in that position. Knight was solid since coming but today I have no words. That said we was behind the 8 ball way before that.


I dont understand not having Balmforth on the bench, if I was to be critical of Carty I find some of his bench choices baffling at times. I think Balmforth would have added something in the last quarter.