Did he ???

Nail on the head...

I think the Wigan game was disappointing because in the previous games our pack has been pretty dominant. We had full availability in the forwards and were in a game where we could have gone top. The fact that the intensity was, if anything, a step down from previous games was the main disappointment for me. As you say we're not the best team in the league and Wigan are at the moment, but to only just keep them to below 50 and to only get 18 of our 24 points when they'd taken their foot off the gas was very disappointing to the 2000 fans who travelled and most of whom probably had to leave work early/make special arrangements to do so.

I think there is some absolute pillocks out there, sack agar after a poor performance at wigan, the same wigan team who are sitting pretty top of the tree, who have just about demolised every challenge put in front of them. And should have beat bradford. Also gone to wire and won not many teams will do that this year. But hey lets sack the coach that has turned us from pretenders to maybe even contenders. Its one game. Get behind the coach the players and see what we do against bradford.

I think Agar is an ok coach. Not a bad one, but not a great one. I am not calling for his head, but I am concerned about the renewing of his contract. His recruitment and retention has been spot on. If we end up doing reasonably ok this season, I think it will be a case of the team of players carrying the coach.

I think we need and deserve a top class coach, especially for the young players coming through. To many young players do not seem to fulfil their potential.

TBH I think we'll do well to finish 6th or above. No shame in that considering where we've come from either.

As a fully paid up Agar out supporter, I feel that to say the reaction has been after one defeat to Wigan is a short sighted. My opinion is that the guy is nowhere near the mark coaching wise and I dont wish to see another season go down the tubes.

Yes we have won 4 out of 6, last year we won 5 out of 6 but the same flaws are still there
1) We dont seem to be able to adapt a game plan to counter opposition strengths
2) We tinker with a winning team Tansey-Whiting, Hall-Whiting, Moa-Radford, Turner-Long
3) Tickle and Radford remain unquenchable penalty machines
4) We become over confident prior to the Crusaders game ( did they forget the last 2 seasons so quickly)
5) We get out enthused in a potential table topper (one again have we forgot the last 2 season already)

I dont accept it's the players as they are coached all week by Agar, ok lets forget about the last two seasons if it makes his record look better but we have still been out enthused in 33% of this seasons games and I am not confident that he can change our gameplan once the other coaches have sussed us out and the dry weather negates our pack somewhat.

Think its going to be hardest season yet to judge any coaches at least for a quite a few more rounds yet. Should Saints, Leeds, Bradford sack there coaches? They have arguably the same strength of squad as us but below us. At this point I would havent have expected any more points than we have even if the games they came from isnt what I expected. Think we can expect the top 5 spots to change weekly. Going to be a strange season.

Tickle seems to have improved in this area this season and his form is spot on

I refuse to take sides in this spat as I think its too early to sack anyone.

I would however question the wisdom of one glaring error of judgement and I have seen plenty more in the last two seasons.

I suspect that one Shaun Long is still carrying his hamstring injury, why was he risked?

I am not having a go, but Rich does seem to leave himself open to not only fans, the media and the board to use things like this. Whilst the pressure to play high earning and capable players like Long are great, the need for doing it right has to come first.

Wouldn`t surprise me if Long didn`t actually pressure Agar into playing him in this game.Hamstring or not.

Having seen Bradford last week when they beat us and again last night on tv when they were at Wire, I can honestly say that I think you'll beat them well.
There were game changing moments at Wigan when had things gone Hull's way the game could have been a lot different.
Had that pass stuck at 12-6.
If three Hull players had not allowed the ball to bounce which gave Roberts the opportunity to score.
Two penalties which didn't find touch.
All mistakes which I'm sure won't be repeated against Bradford nor perhaps for the rest of the season.
You have a good pack, good halves and Agar needs to settle his backs.