best post for along time..couldnt agree more

Monaghan has more ability in his little finger than Thorman has in his entire body. He hasn't exactly been in sparkling form since joining Wire but is still capable of putting in performances that Thorman can only dream about.

agree with that aswell

Horne and Briers have different skills I'd take Monaghan any day over Thorman.

Have to disagree with that.

They have a better set of props and a canny scrum half in briers. Their backs are nothing special man for man (imagine the outcry if we had signed Mathers!).

A very well coached team now though.....

Horne isn't currently playing halfback.

Monaghan is a lot better than Thorman, although I'll grant you that he doesn't show it often enough.

When?????

He has been a big waste of money....check the Wire board about him...they cant wait for him to bugger off.

He's crap as well.

And where saying the same about Thorman after only half the season.

Oh ffs......nitpicking to back up a weak argument.

Yeah but he has always been crap....i wouldnt have either of them.

Mattew Head over them both.

But I don't think any of us expected a huge influencial signing in Thorman like Wire did in Monaghan though and there will be a big difference money wise too.

Wire have always had a good team on paper but haven't had a coach capable of bringing the best out of them to play as a team, us on the other hand are worse off as we don't have the players to work with so from my point of view its goign to take a couple of years to turn it around even if we did get a super coach in.