Not read the whole thread so apologies if this has been said already.



1. Didn't want him in the first place, he was rubbish for Hudds which is why they got rid.

2. I was prepared to accept his signing on a 1 year deal if it meant we could use the time to find a really top quality 7 for next season.

3. If his contract is extended and we dont bring a top SH next season I will NOT be renewing my season pass.

It hurts to say this but we miss cook so much and we just have not replaced him with any one Webster would of been worth keeping instead of Thorman. We was linked with Jamie saword who is at St George now but we did not wish to pay that little bit more for him now he is the best up and coming player in the NRL as that is what they are saying in OZ and i have seen him play and i agree. We was also linked with Dobson and we went out to OZ to get his signature and surprise surprise we lost out because we would not pay that little extra fro him. We would rather get average players or players past there best like DYKES any one agree

Thorman's kicking was poor last night but he wasn't given much chance to look good as he was taking each kick from behind his 40.

Jamie Soward would have been a great signing but it never happened.

The truth often hurts mate.





Yes.

Its his job to direct play and dictate when the forwards run, so it was also his fault we were only getting upto the 40 before the 5th tackle.



Also if his kicks had gone to ground, Wire would not have been able to pin us so far back in our half and we would have made it past 40 yards, Wire was taking the first tackle on their own 40 due to the kicks dropping right into their hands.

Even his drop-outs are woefull. I mean it's not like you've got to pinpoint the fullback or wingman like he normally manages. It's a case of get it as far down the pitch as you can, he can't even do that. Not one redeeming feature of his play, and last night was almost beyond belief. As for Judas, i don't think anyone at the club is brave enough to even try to get him back. Don't think it would ever happen but in the cold light of day you have to ask yourself whether we'd be a better side with a performing Paul Cooke....Of course we would.

Why would he want to come back??

Although I agree we have not replaced him.(I.M.H.O.)

Hang on, hang on.



I think there's a little too much negativity around Throman. For someone to pick out one of three players on a piece of grass an acre in size in no mean feat, just think, the ball could go absolutely anywhere !! It takes som skill to find the man every time . . . . . . . . .

Guess his new 3 year deal will have people topping themselves then

Please tell me it's not with us.