It is not a question of a caretakers ability though Kosh, fans want to see the club act, Agar has failed and the fans are getting very restless, if they stick with Agar fans will stop going, if they act and use a caretaker (with the view to replacing) the fans will see this as a positive step in the right direction, we will fail to achieve with Agar anyway so we may as well take steps in the right direction irrelevant of risking a few games.

You need to read that again, and my comments that preceded it. At no point did I suggest that you weren't a fan, and I specifically stated that it wasn't about being a better/worse fan. My point consistently throughout the entire exchange was that I couldn't see how someone who describes themselves as a fan could want us to lose games.

Yeah ok mate. I think I've got you bang to rights, if that quote isn't suggesting that I'm not a fan then I don't know what it is.

My opinion is at least consistent and expressed coherently. That doesn't make it 'worth more' than yours, but changing your mind from one week to the next doesn't exactly lend any credibility to your stance.

I think the club will see it on a season basis. So they'll be looking for an improvement on 16 from 27 last season and better things from the cup. 3 games in, after 16 from 27 last season, wont be the time when they make a decision to sack Agar. Not a good start for sure but the club will give it time. They gave him a 2 year extension, rightly or wrongly, which means an imminent decision is even less likely.

so now the club should sack every coach that has a run of bad results because the fans show a banner ( all 9 of them) where does that end though is the question????
whats positive today will be de ja vu tomorrow...
think back to how thrilled everyone was with sharps appointment!!!
Lets the season run its course and what ever comes comes...

something no one has eluded to yet is that JR and KH want sucess too you know and they watch every game and speak to folk!! they know exactly what is going on and will act if they feel they need to but just now its just too early simple as that

Precisely, I don't want us to rush into another appointment.

That's doubtless their intended policy, but there's no denying that consistent fan pressure has the potential to force change.

Well three losses on the bounce, conceding 86 points on the way (28 points per game), technically bottom of Super League, only team without a win this year. That's all about this season.

I do remember finishing in the playoffs. I also remember that we should have finished higher up than we did in the table, so should have had a different draw, and I also remember surrendering to our greatest rivals in that play off game. Maybe we shouldn't remember that and just focus on this season eh? Oh hang on...

Never changed my stance but as i say (read the posts mate) I agree with much of what is being said because its plain for all to see.. however my credibility doesnt even enter into it mate because its no more or less than yours its all about opinion and sorry if you were one of the 9 and i wasnt

It's not a 'run of bad results', it's a 40-odd percent win ratio for the three years he's been in charge. And it is disingenuous - silly even - to suggest that only nine fans want rid of Agar.



And then we can write another season off and look forward to more of the same in 2012...

What utter twaddle
3 out of 11 !!! and those wins were Crusaders, London and the Dobbins!!
We have only averaged 16 points in those 11 games, yet conceded an average of 26.
Simply not good enough.

correct , after three weeks i agree its too early to make a shout on the head coach !! we have a possible (on paper0 7/8 wins ahead of us that will / should put us approx 6th on my calcs
i will return to this in 6 games and re ask you this same question!! lets hope your wrong and i am right i am sure you agree sweetie??

*shrugs* You can read it how you like, that's not how it was intended. You can also look back through my entire history of posting - I'm an argumentative sod but I've never got involved in better/worse fan arguments. Questioning how you can reconcile being a fan and wanting us to lose is not the same as saying you aren't a fan. It's questioning how you can reconcile the two.