Just to be clear, this is the Westerman who got Murdoch's MOM tonight and has been one of our best forwards this season?

Arundel? Really?

Westerman played ok tonight, but is still too inconsistent IMO and I think we need someone who can direct play better at Loose

Not sure who Daniel Morgan is. Brian Smith is so well thought of he's coaching the US. He's never won a trophy. Don't know enough about the other two to comment.

Who would you replace Holdsworth with? Which two props would you bring in?

One of the best games I've seen Westerman play for us. He was everywhere and ran his blood to water.

I agreed with FC Baldy on something earlier, now he's back to his old tricks.

Tickle has been $hite for a while now..knock-onathon with him!!I'd keep westerman, and drop yeamo and start with arundel...

No...as i was unable to attend tonight due to illness i dont know how he played but i havent been a fan since we signed him...far too inconsistent .

Arundel is an average and competent player, but is he going to break us in to the top4?

he's also spent most of the season injured, oh well only another 3 years of his deal to go...another top signing for the club

I'd say that Westerman was one of our best forwards for the first half of the season. Since then, he's been quite ordinary.

If you insist.

Daniel Morgan - Has a big role in Australia, doesn't want to live in England.
Brian Smith - Could be available, still does coaching clinics. I'm guessing he's been sounded out for a few jobs though and has probably declined them all.
Jason Taylor - Sydney Roosters
Steve Foulkes - Why? Based on what?

Players out

Crooks
Westerman
Johnson
Holdsworth

Players in

Broughton/BJB
Big hairy ar$ed prop x2

So we lose a half back and don't replace them? We sack Westerman, who has his brain farts but is easily one of our better players and don't bring in another back rower? A position were alreadly short in next year?

Absolute s***e tonight.
Pearson must act . Gentle is out of his depth. Adam's problem was putting his faith in the wrong people to advise him.
Our recruitment is very average . Pitts , Galea , Johnson , Crookes , Watts have all disappointed.
Even Ellis has failed to deliver.
We again have no leadership on the field and our forwards are weak .
Tough off season ahead . Our off season recruitment will be average from lower placed Clubs.
Same old Hull FC . All talk and don't worry bel13ve and all that clap trap!!

Daniel Anderson i meant smart ar$e...i was just throwing names about...as for props...dont know whois available here or down under as i dont watch aussie rugby but the 2 we are linked with at Cas wont do it for us.

Do you lot do this everytime you lose ?

Fair enough, but I can assure you he was anything other than poor tonight. True passion and was putting himself about in defence.

You could just as easily have meant Justin Morgan, so wasn't being 'smart'.