At the moment.....carvell he's been pretty good for wire of late

Luke Briscoe

Swain

The likes of Mick Harrison and Trevor Skerrett would have beasted Carvell if they played/trained the same as modern day pros. I'd have Harrison in my 13 any day of the week.

Overall though if I had to have one player from all that i've seen I'd have to go with Topliss, skill, bravery and tactically superior. I reckon the only reason he didn't get so many caps for GB is that he played for Wakey at a time when they were unsuccessful & unfashionable.

I agree with everything you say about Toppo,a complete player and a born leader.Seen some great players at Hull over the last 40--50 years but he was one of the best leaders.Remember when he finished playing for one of the Aussie sides,they offered him a blank cheque to stay,not many British players can say that.

Spot on ,I'd have Knocker imho

I asked my Dad the same question. He's 80 and has been following Hull since the war.

Without hesitation he said Bruce Ryan. A flying Australian winger who beat people for fun.

He played for Hull for three seasons form 1947-1950, before Leeds bought him for a World Record fee of £4,500.

No doubt tipped off by an external source!!!

Knocker - God in hull shirt. The loudest I ever heard threepenny was when his name was announced in the team for a derby when he came back from an injury. The place erupted. the game was won in that moment

Duncan Jackson was another great player Mike Scott our Johnny W the list is endless ..the 4 New Zealand lads could add something to a team I have seen some great player at Hull FC over the years

To fit into our current squad I would agree with the vote for Richie Barnett. The guy was pure class & just seemed to glide through defences. He could also put in some massive hits in defence. Wish we could have had him a few years earlier.

Mick Crane and Richie Barnett

If we base it on requirements/positions for next year then as follows:

second row: Len Casey (hard as nails, tighten the defence, when he played full game if not sent off)

Centre: Gary Schofield ( fast as lightening, with brilliant rugby brain)

Past....Knocker

Present....Danny Brough