We need to strengthen in the backs. Tansey, Briscoe, Yeaman, Whiting, Turner all under contract for next season already. Would be surprised if we kept Hall.

Ive got to agree , As soon as we have the wingers fit again , He'll be back in the reserves .

he is no better than he was on his debut, therefore I think we should get rid

add reece to that list! that leaves hall,calders and tuffour staring at the exit door.

Time to let Hall go, He'd never be a starting centre for any of the top 6 sides in the league and we want to be challenging the top so afraid his time to move on has come.

He's had his chance and as exciting as he is with some open space in front of him his defence is one of the worst I've seen in SL. That award had to go to Chris Thorman at Headingley though!!

Reading the posts in this thread it seems to me that most of us wouldn't be bothered if he left.

I recall that when his contract was up last time most of us were keen that he should stay, which suggests he has not really progressed since then.

I would keep him if we can, but only at the right price. If he has inflated ideas of his worth then let him go.

He has got (another) chance to impress tonight. Lets see whether he takes it.

He has had a contract offer, not a lot of money though.

I think most agree he has not progressed sufficiently to warrant a new contract.

He has been poor in defence in every game I have ever seen him in since his debut. He does not deserve a contract at any wage. Even if he has a good game tonight I really hope he doesn’t get another contract. He is a liability and when he plays, teams target him all day long and are always successful against him.

Aye. Look how he got targeted by Saints - four tries run in on his wing and he was only on the bench.

Wrong.

I've had some time to calm down after his performance against Quins (which was desperate) and am now hoping he will have a good game tonight.

My feeling is that he is not a revolving door like some poor defenders but that he just shows himself up positionally and particularly by rushing out of the line. If he could have one game where he holds his position defensively then we might be praising him instead of hoping that he leaves.

What he has in attack can't be taught - it is natural talent: I only hope that what he lacks in defensive nous can be taught.

I don't think anyone is saying things are perfect when he doesn't play. But they're usually a hell of a lot worse when he does.