YES

Lyne made as many metres as the forwards, carried the ball well and cleared his lines very well. Bit of a balls up for their second try but the other two weren't just his fault, was left isolated.

Out of his depth tonight and hopefully fans will stop calling for him to play. He is not ready, simple as.

Hall should have played no question!!

Just to add to that, don't think he should of played, not a 'nice' game to play in, would of preferred his debut to be at KC. Hall back next week. Looked promising though.

i thought reece did ok, he wasnt helped by the experienced players who didnt turn up tonight , he will have learned alot more tonight and will be better for the experience. 2 years time he will be a regular in the side. out of his depth ? no its a learning curve and briscoe was also left exposed tonight.

Richard Agar was in a no win situation tonight regarding Reece Lynn, we all wanted him to be given a chance and Agar did that. In hindsight that was probably the wrong decision.

I remember seeing Kirk Yeaman make his debut at Boulevard against St Helens and Martin Gleeson absoloutly ripped him apart, now Kirk bounced back well and represented his country.

Reece Lynn will become a better player for this experience i have no doubts, short term we may have lost 2 points but long term we have a hell of a prospect on our hands who now knows the difference between the U20s and SL level.

The same Hall that was just as bad at Wigan? Not the best of games but he wasn't even the worst Hull player on the pitch today.

Seems to have inherited Hall's scapegoat mantle judging by the way Agar subbed him off.

Thought the kid did ok and looks a very good prospect,by the way can our full back tackle?,if Briscoe or Motu would of been at full back tonight at least two of those tries wouldn't of been scored.

are you smashed, he looked lost in the headlights in any way you want to look at it, out of his depth by a thousand miles

Hall wasn't the worst player at Wigan.

Said the same thing at the game. Subbing him off basically gave the impression he was to blame for the defeat (when does a winger ever get subbed normally?) when in reality our FB was just as culpable for the 2 trys in the corner. It was a nervous debut but all of this out of his depth rubbish is total bollox. He dealt with the physicality ok but our defensive structure out wide is so poor our wingers are constantly exposed.

We don't have another Hall do we?

It was not Lyne's fault but he should never have played, he's not ready.

there are no positives from tonight, a lot of people are very very upset tonight and the only one that isnt is agar...
isnt a coach meant to be passionate??? sounded like sharpe all over again

Who said he was?