Started off great but hasnt performanced very well last few weeks ( although thats mainly due to the fact the rest of the side and the forwards arent getting on top )

Too early to give a full judgement, his kicking was atrocious on Sunday, and i don;t know why they bother to kick for touch at a penalty because he can't go more than 10 metres.
Think he will fare better if whiting is in the side as he can take some of the kicking away from him to concentrate more on the game in the middle.

Craig Hall. Best performance. Great night. Most of the players there.

Other than 1 half decent performance at bradford he's been awful. Kicking poor on the whole and his decision making is reminiscent of a 19 year old tommy lee. Thank fook he's only signed for 1 year, although I expect the club to announce an extension soon

i fooking hope not, would like to think he was just a stop gap and we have somebody better lined up for next year

You just know that's not the case though

we can live in hope jake

Has created/been involved in the majority of our tries this season as you might expect as a half back. Short kicking better than long but recently lacking confidence - takes the kick option too often where the pass would be better. Being targeted in defence a bit but no worse than R Horne in that facet. Would be OK behind a stronger more dominant pack but probably not a long term solution.

Sums up my opinion as well. Particularly the bit in bold.

Can be brilliant and can be awful, if he can get somewhere inbetween on a regular basis then he will go okay. Still can't see him being here next season though and his overuse of kicks can be very annoying.

I would keep him for next year with signing of additional half back. He can cover at half back and full back, hes no world beater but would be decent cover.

His poor options taken would be less important if the game wasnt dependent on them. We should never have been close with Salford meaning his kick near the end should never have been important. Was a woeful 2nd tackle play. Ive seen him do that in a few games and get the feeling no other players are on the same wavelength as theres never a chaser. He needs to let his team mates know what he's doing.

Im still fully in support of Thorman and dont think our tactics help him. Why did we go wide in the first 10 mins and score, and then only repeat it once because we dropped the ball? (we seem scared of trying things)

He didn't drop the mic or run off to the side of the stage and fall off then?

Cant believe I'm saying this but I would rather have a battered and bruised Adam Dykes ahead of Thorman at present!

A good half back plays IN FRONT OF THE PACK NOT BEHIND THEM

We need pro active half back not re-active. its their job to MAKE things happen not wait for someone else to do their job