Fair enough bud.

Sorry - your argument seemed to be based on scoring record.

Hall's defence is an issue but I still think it could be dealt with if he was playing in the centres and the rest of our defensive structure was working. IMO his attacking threat makes it worthwhile persevering. If we kept him and Yeaman as centres it opens up places elsewhere to spend cash and/or overseas places.

I'm not Yeaman's biggest fan but he's been playing well so far this season and earned a new contract IMO. I'm not even particularly concerned about the 3 years like some others - he'll only be 30 at the end of that time, and good English centres are thin on the ground. He'll be an asset.

only without the off field issues, ie had the ability to be a regular international player, but never fulfilled his potential. I hope Kirk proves me wrong over the next 3 years, but I doubt it.[/quote]

-never in a million years

Like Kosh has pointed out, there isn't exactly a massive pool of talented british players to bring in. Yeaman has probably missed Cooke more than most as he was his main supply line. However with the rugby we have played the last 2 and a half seasons a centre/winger of any calibre would struggle to be getting on the scoresheet regularly.

His defense is fine and if he is given the chance to attack he will, he also has the added benefit of coming in and running the ball from dummy half to take some pressure off the forwards from time to time.

maybe not,but i don't expect him to toss his fc career away like kingy did.

put Yeamo in Leeds, Wigan and Saints team and he would be unstoppable as they have the right players to use him correctly.

he would.whether i would have given him 3 years instead of 2 i'm still unsure tho'

Spot on

To be honest thats Yeamo he would sign for FC life if he could.

Who'd have thought that an outside back in a team that has struggled to score tries for teh last 3 years hasn't scored many tries in the last 3 years. Amazing

It's the sensible move, put him in a decent side & he'd probably rip up trees. Get rid & we'd be left with what in the centres? I still think he could have done better over the last couple of seasons even given the poor supply & poor team, I dont think he does enough work tbh and his passing(or lack thereof) has shown he's a greedy sod at times.

which is spot on, he can hold to the ball when the best option is passing. Yeamo will be first to admit that sometimes he gets it wrong but hey given only you have a split second to make a decision that the way it goes sometimes.

this has improved lately,but let's hope that continues.