Thank you Kosh, I have now editted that for clarity too

Doubt we ever will though thats the problem isnt it!
but i have no doubt he would excel there

The thread is about who you would keep not who you would replace with, please stay on topic, replacement possibles are available in every other thread on the forum please re read them ... !!

well if I couldn't replace them I'd keep them all.

without change the playing pool and thought process stagnates, players will always become available it is i guess all about finding the correct replacements which is a job Kath and co seemed to do well after King and co , however as i said this thread is about who would you keep not who would you replace them with ..

Good post east hull fc fan.

IMO if calderwood has gone injury prone we need two wingers, and move briscoe to the centres.

how is that the right answer when he talks about replacements?

Have you taken your medication?

Yes. Will he be able to? Doubt it unless ooc which i'm not sure about.
Is there any other young props about?

Would be tough on Calderwood if not offered a new contract but as we are so short on outside backs it is imperative we have players contracted with a reasonable level of health. If he can stay fit after this new setback i would keep him as I think we need specialists in the wing position. Yeaman for me would go, just don't see enough of a complete centre personally. Also with him playing the game so flat, the winger outside him is often wasted.

LMS, Watts and Wheeldon are ooc.

I don't know about any others.

your continued abuse and attempts to derail the thread are childish at best , act somewhat grown up like others who are trying to answer and discuss like adults, feel free to join in or visit the many other threads you can rub yourself against some one elses leg

I know LMS is mentioned a lot but again unless there is other things going on behind the scenes he always looked happy there, big fish small pond kinda stuff...
Dont know enough about Watts
Wheeldon apart from being younger is no better than what we already have, similar to higgins etc.. a few good young lads in the NL1 but are we in the market for projects again??...