He's scored 6 tries in 9 games. That's second only to Briscoe's 7 in 10, and one more than Yeaman's 5 in 11. That still makes him our top try-per-game player, even in a season where he's mainly played out of position.

The fact that this seems to have escaped you leads me to believe that you aren't actually watching Hall at all.

I dont disagree but he apparently jumps out the line intentionaly to try and disrupt the flow of attack. He has also scored 7 tries in his last 5 games so go figure.

Fair enough. Although you do know that the top teams have on average 3 overseas players in their backlines, don't you?

See my response to GU above.

Hall scores more tries per game than anyone else in the side, and has done for the last few seasons. Without half backs and with no real service. For some reason this is continually overlooked or dismissed because of his unarguable problems in defence.

But the thread was started to slate him for his performance last night.

No it doesnt Briscoe has the better ratio

OK fair point but his net contribution is what counts and if anything his defence is getting worse and not better. I've said a few times if he could defend he would be an outstanding centre.

And if Whiting had dealt with a bog standard high kick they wouldn't have scored their first. Does that mean we ought to slate him as well?

Most player made mistakes yesterday - even Whiting made a few. With different luck some of those mistakes would have cost us points. There's often a fine line between success and failure.

Oh sorry for stepping so badly out of line.

And if he was kept in the centres and taught to defend like a centre he would be.

The point is that Whiting 's performances are consistently better than Hall's. If Hall could defend to the required standard do you think these threads would appear ? Of course they wouldn't. Instead there would be threads calling for his international inclusion. The fact that these threads appear and the international calls don't says far more than anything.