In our last two games Miller has been in our top 3 performers, but he won't get any credit. He never will. Westerman was the scapegoat in 2011/12. Seem to remember a certain poster sticking up for him too!

This full season millers had 3 try assists & 1clean break, so how & who says he's been in or top 3 of performers? Shauls,Hadley,Feka,Westy,,yeamo,houghton,Ellis were all better against Kr, he was subbed at Leeds as he created nothing & didn't look like it either, but feel free to go on SL website & have a look, my lad can play & kick better then him already & he's not even 14.

Difficult to use stats as your only performance indicator, Scott Moore has 50% more try assists than Luke Walsh & Rangi Chase. Maybe we should get Koucash to give your lad a call?

League position tells you nothing either you will be saying next? Can't you answer the question?

Intresting to see horney is our top assists player with 7. I feel he has to come back in one of the halfback positions as rankin and miller aren't doing enough.

Tbf the try assist stat is not really an accurate 1 to use. You only get awarded a try assist for the final pass of the move, if a player throws a pass to make a break they get nothing.

Just wondered where 1865 is getting the info that Miller is in the top 3 performers from? He hasn't been awarded many Albert Goldthorpe medals either.

Yes we heard it all
Our great defence last year was all to do with Radford.? Gentles gone and taken "Radfords" defence with him?

We're great in attack? Well obviously gentles poor attack has gone now. In fact it's so good......... We have less competitions points than this time last year.

For the record this isn't an attack on Radford, the change in coach was Mr Pearson's call. A call that has taken us backwards.

I think [i'injured'[/i is more appropriate for McDonnel.

What a difference a year makes indeed! That was quite a depressing read. How could it all have gone so wrong when we looked to be making some real progress? Seems to be an age old problem with FC.



Agree with a lot of this to be honest. Our form certainly dipped once we got to the business end of the Challenge Cup. I think it was probably AP that targeted the CC as I recall him making comments in last years pre-season about it but PG probably agreed that it was an achievable goal. Sadly we showed that we weren't good enough to fight on both fronts but I believe we could have got there under PG. We were a good, solid, outfit under PG. Maybe not the most exciting but for the most part a difficult outfit to play against.

I bet those people who were asking to get rid of PG wish they could have him back now...

old saying "you don't know what you've got until its gone"

And could have started developing into something. I agree we were too led by the Mcrae/Howes axis, but once Bomber went that could have been changed