Or as with Tom Briscoe we work out how to give him better ball so that people talk about his 3 tries rather than his defensive errors.

Don't think our attacking play has been too bad this year as the points for column indicates. Better quality ball will help any back as you say. As for Briscoe he has much to work on. I said a couple of weeks ago he should be the back under most pressure to keep his place.

What annoys me about Hall is his jumping out of the line in defence either to intercept or tackle the receiver, most of the time his timing is off leaving an overlap for the opposition.

What like Yeaman?

is that not more down to our defensive pattern meaning our outside backs on both sides end up jumping out due to overlaps?

Dropping hall is the easy option for agar. He obviously doesn't rate him. For Hall's sake he needs to move on (unless we have a new coach by then) at the end of the season. Shame as he would be excellent if given a decent run in his preferred position.

radford was rubbish last Friday but I bet he doesn't drop him for moa

I think that by enlarge I would agree with you Dave however I think that although he is a potent attacker, at present as the last match highlights on the club site show his defence at Wigan was woeful at times! OK he scored one try but he conceided two directly because of his actions. Once he came out of the line and missed his man completely the second time he got sucked in and left his winger. 12 points in a critical first half; game gone! Sadly although he was far from the only ones at fault in the overall performance I guess his mistakes do stick out a bit! He'll be back!

Factually correct. Tough to pick out one guy but the fact is he was shocking defensively in the first half. Hull FC TV shows it.

As someone else has said none of us know how players go in training either which I'm sure also has a bearing on squad selection. Hall will be back if his character is up to it.

if hall was directly responsible for allowing 2 tries at wigan who's fauly were the other 6

I think that the Fev mafia are safe whilst don agar is in charge

Agar's comments on RH were as follows:
Calderwood back as first choice winger
Richard Whiting has played consistently well this season and was one of our better players against Wigan and therefore earned the right to keep the shirt
Craig Hall didn't play that well against Wigan but that was in the context of being uncomfortable out of position as he's not a winger.

None of these comments or the decision are that unreasonable. Anyone would think we've got Inglis available but are choosing not to select him because we've got the option of Brendan Hill in the 3/4s.