about time we had another fans forum, in fact we should have 3 every season, one at that start of the season, one halfway through and one at the end

the next one should have the board of directors on the panel so we can all have a good slagging session would sound very entertaining live on KCFM

I have said this numerous times but i cannot believe we haven't got an independant fans group on the go...i know it's the age old argument of people organising it etc, etc but that is the same for all such groups and most (if not all) SL teams have them (don't they?).

A collective voice that can present a constructive critique of the club is a healthy option to have.

It's a by product of on field success and momentum. By definition it's not as important as without the success we won't keep it

We have won only one trophy since 1991. Hardly grounds for claiming that we've been successful. So how did we achieve the A grade licence on that basis ?

Because the CC win and the GF appearance and consistent top 6 finishes (1 point), increased attendances above 10k( 2 points) and turnover over £4m (1 point) took us from a grade B to a grade A. Do you think we'd have achieved these if we'd been fighting relegation every year?

Do you really not understand this or are you just being awkward to try and look big and clever?

On the other hand St Helens, the most successful side on the field in recent SL and CC history only achieved a B grade I believe. So success on the field is clearly not the be all and end all as you claim. Incidentally despite all the gnashing of teeth and hand wringing from the likes of yourself we remain 7th in the league and in a playoff spot - enough for us to obtain the point for contributing to the competition as the new playoff structure stands. This despite another crippling injury list and visa issues. Ou crowd average will be well over 10K this year.

If Hull slip to a B grade as a result of falling crowds and league finishing position in the next couple of years then so be it. As far as I know that will still qualify us to play in the top competition. We have a superb community and youth structure, we play at a top ground and we have a large base of committed fans who will not walk away when the going gets tough. Maybe not 10K of them but 7-8K have the stomach for it. We will remain competitive as the import quotas tighten and our younger British players gain more experience. The club needs to combine that with the recruitment of top quality overseas signings which will hold up the crowd levels and improve performance. Despite poor performances this year we are 2 maybe 3 players away from competing in the top 4.



I'll leave the trying to look big and clever to you you're a past master at it I can see. How's the revolution coming along by the way ?

Why exactly do Hull FC not talk to HISA. And is FC VOICES still on the go?

Totally agree I have posted the same on many occassions trouble is have you noticed how it all goes quiet when you do! All of a sudden the thread is off away from the subject! Surely there are some of the more outspoken on here who would give it a go!

And here

Id be in

Here!

lets just say Humberside are still more popular than me