He isn't rubbish, he's had a poor season amongst many who have also, he just gets noticed more in his positions.

Agar has a habit of knocking the confidence out of players, maybe he should be the one answering the critics.

he is rubbish because if he wasnt he would be playing all game and we would be doing better because with no one in his position is creating anything. the most thorman does is a stupid little drop off that lets face it doesnt beat anyone but berrigan is playing ok there but he is miles better at hooker

Thorman has been consistently bad over the course of the season andthoroughly deserves all his criticism.

agreed it does my head in how people can say he is not rubbish tell me what good thing he has done for hull

Couple Hull fans I know don't believe me, but he was excellent for you guys against us on several occassions the last couple of years, constant attacking threat.

Would you have him in the Rovers squad?

I thought not, so why should he be good enough for us.

dont get me wrong he played some good games for huddersfield but has come to hull and been a totally different player

And Briscoe was rubbish playing for us remember



Swings and roundabouts chief.

I felt really sorry for Thorman on Friday. Shoved out of the way at the back when Tansey went off. When he was at 7 he at least tried.

he tries to hard and comes up with mistakes

At least give me a chance to answer.

We don't need him, we thought Dobson was worth the money remember, but would I have Thorman at Rovers, we could do, and have in the past done worse. Under a decent coach like Morgan he would maybe regain the form he showed a couple of years back.

morgan is a good coach but i think its not just to him lets face it the team are playing well together and cookie and dobson are linking and we have a missing link i.e thorman