Quote Mrs Barista="Mrs Barista"You can tell me a million times. '"
I'll certainly try.
Quote Mrs Barista="Mrs Barista"IMO a specialist full back can deal with the high ball. '"
Something which Tony does on the vast majority of occasions. And it's a fairly minor part of the game anyway. It's not often that you'll get more than two or three a game going to the fullback and if he deals with 90% (I'd be alright with less, TBH, if they don't cost us) that's fine with me. As I've said plenty of times, it's an area he could be stronger in, but it's nowhere near the problem it's made out to be.
Quote Mrs Barista="Mrs Barista"I'd be fine with Briscoe's "averageness" if that meant being able to defuse a high ball, clear his goal line, defend courageously and back up Richard Horne for try after try
'"
All of those things you mention are fairly minor parts of the game (except clearing the goal line, but I suspect you mean that differently to how I'd view it, as Briscoe certainly isn't good in that area AFAIC). Not the attributes that should be looked for as the most important things for a fullback, yet they remain so in this country. And we wonder why we get our s handed to us every time we come up against the Aussies, who play fullbacks who have a little more to their game. Maybe we could learn something from that.
Quote Mrs Barista="Robbo4"I'd just like to throw into the mixing pot that this long held belief that Motu is somehow a hooker is complete rubbish IMO. He cant pass for a start.'"
But he played there for NZ a couple of times. He [imust[/i be a hooker.
(He can pass, but it's short, defence-splitting passes in a tight space that he's good at rather then long, fast, flat, accurate passes, repeatedly, from dummy half, where he's not good at all.)
Quote Mrs Barista="BalearicHullFan"Possibily the biggest load of rubbish I've read on this forum in a while. '"
Coming up with a decent counter argument should be easy then.