catalan v hudds

luke robinson sent off for off the ball challenge!

there is a link on giants forum if you want to see the game

He has been played there most of the season, Brown thinks it's a good position for him, i don't see it myself!!

The players i would want at Hull are Makinson, Walmsley and Percival are they the 2 or 3 you want at Hull?

Walmsley definitely .

Hey ! London beat Saints acadeamy team.

Suppose he has got good hands and obviously good defender! But I'm not sure! Saints definately need a few heads back!

roby, walmsley and manu were who I was thinking of and would improve us (although manu hasn't really done much for them when he's played so maybe that one is more of an emotive one for me). Don't think makinson or Percival would get into our 1st choice 17 but would take Percival as he looks quality.

Can't remember a time for many years when saints had so few quality players in their ranks. They have a massive rebuilding job to do in the next few years

Saints are one of the clubs desperate for a half back. Hope we tie up a deal for miller soon!.
Saints have always dealt with transition really well but it looks like there's a big job to do there.
What worked for brown at giants won't go down well with saints supporters.

Exactly. Saints are suffering from a lack of decent halves and a big injury list. Makes the game really difficult does that regardless of what club it is.

Their recruitment has been poor in recent seasons. hohaia (sp), perry and laffranchi are big money signings who have been nowhere near value

Not going well for Rovers, biggest cheer so far by the Rovers fans, was when the ref pulled Leeds up for a forward pass, sandy excuses are already there for him.

Looking at the table, a decent win against London would be fairly handy as Bradford host Leeds. Could do with Widnes beating Saints too.

Went to watch Rovers v Leeds today, never heard so much booing and foooorward in my life. I honestly couldn't believe what I was hearing.

What was your impartial assessment of the ref?

Hicks is poor but he had no impact on the result. First try had a dubious last pass, all the others were fine. Leeds got some calls first half and Rovers got some second half.

Difference was Leeds defence was outstanding and Rovers was poor. Leeds skill in attack along with offloads won them the game.