It's the dunce's cap for me Panda 92

the single most idiotic invention ever, well, after caffeine free coffee!

Has Ian Smith been paid off?

"Top 4 Refereeing"

Don't you just love it.

it's pathetic, may as well just skip to L**ds v Saint in the GF and not bother with the season.

Some shocking decisions from all officials involved

Ithink Ian Smith and Silverwood could win this game by themselves................ If Stains can keep them fir they could easily win this comp

Personally, I'm not a fan.

If salford had some decent forwards they'd have ran away with this

It's the subtleties they get away with. Just before the 40/20 at the ptb Saints markers were everywhere except square thanks to a good break through the line by Salford. The ref ignored it.

"Top 4 Refereeing" is at its best when it ignores situations that don't benefit the big guns. As ever with refereeing it's the decisions that aren't given against the "BIG" team that have far more influence than those that are. Especially when the same offences are pinged the other way.

I think you are Mr B. We have been having the exact same discussion here. What's the penalty count - 7-2?

I paricularly liked the VR freeze frame of not one, but two, Saints players using Ashley Gibson's head as a lever to prevent him scoring a try, followed by a 'no try - third tackle attack' decision.