Did you really ask that!

So if I go to work and kick and punch some-one I should be treated differently if I only punched them the once!

Haven't you got any pots to wash?

Exactly, everyone on here was saying we needed a signing or 2 to add a bit of depth & ensure that we don't chuck the kids in at the deep end. We've now done that & quite a lot of people aren't willing to give those a chance. Most of the kids close to stepping up are 2nd rows, what chance would they have had if we had of signed a top quality 2nd row aswell as what we've already got?

But the offences weren't carried out in his work place so it's a false argument.

Woah...argue the point but keep the sexism out of it!!!!

I don't really rate Martin Aspinwall. He's going to be a squad player at best, which I suppose will provide us with some depth, but it's a poor signing in my opinion.

Can't say I'm ecstatic about this signing but then I'm not devastated by it like some. On a 1 year deal he will add a bit of depth in an area we are short, if we see the Aspinwall that played for Huddersfield he will have been a shrewd signing if not its only a year deal.

We have to remember that most of the playing squad had already been signed before AP bought the club which has made it difficult for anyone to come in and pull rabbits out the hat that simply are not there. I think some of the signings are simply to fill the void for a season until Gentle can have a complete and direct input.

Lets see what Gentle can do with the players at his disposal before we condemn them.

If you go into work and punch someone you'll be treated differently if you go into work and murder someone.

Surely it's more down to the defensive structures that were in place rather then the players? Under the old regime no matter who we had signed for the right hand side would have struggled so lets see how they get on under Gentle? Also think it well help quite a bit that Martin is in fact a right centre so is familiar with playing on that side.