So if they saw the light and binned agar you'd welcome sharp back then with him being such a good coach?

I personally wouldnt take Sharp back at all but then I would never argue against his record of taking Hull FC to their only Grand Final in the Super League era. His signings and bad luck after this determined his future IMO.

I don't think there is a single Saints fan who wants Sharp as our next coach.

Apparently there are a dozen contenders and our Chief will announce who has the dubious privilege of getting the job in July. I hope that whoever it is, is a gifted coach, actually has a personality and can also wear shades in a sexy fashion.

Would you take Agar?

Occasionally we looked accomplished/skilful, but I don't think we ever looked to have flair/invention. I could respect the organisation and discipline of the team at the time, but I didn't admire the style we played. Part of the magic of watching a pro side to me is seeing them do things others simply can't, not just seeing them as essentially a bunch of more efficient amateurs being consistent.

Don't forget Civoniceva.

I thought it was Hutchie that raised that name

Berrigan has been a bad signing, we should of kept Godwin and rotated him with Houghton and used his Berrigans money elsewhere, been a huge disappointment in my opinion.

Sing was a very poor signing also, a quota winger is a waste of a quota spot when other areas of the team need improving first. Never lived up to the hype again.

Head was only a short term signing and as good as Dykes was, he never played. Byrne was another waste of a quota spot, once again could of been used elsewhere. Cusack has been a very poor signing, no better than what we've got rid of for not apparently been good enough.

His other oversea signing Maiava has got to the worst signing in the clubs recent history.

Overall, during Sharps reign, the squad that had been built by McRae and Kear was dismantled through his obsession with bringing in Aussies.

Ever thought that Houghton's development has been aided by Berrigan though? We've been fortunate with Houghton that he's had 2 fine hookers to learn from, I doubt Godwin could have helped him as much, even though he was a decent player. I personally think Berrigan has been about as good as he's been able to be, team failings have hindered him.



Again, team failings did not help Sing. It was evident to anyone that he still knew how to finish, and if we'd played to his strengths he could have been excellent. For example, we didn't kick to his corner anywhere near enough.



Pretty much agree, but I would alter it slightly. Cusack was good enough, he just wasn't any/much better than what is available over here, so agree completely that he's been a relative waste of a quota spot.



Yup, pretty much.

He's been by far our best player in his three years here. He was pretty much a one man team in his first year and really couldn't have done much more given what he's had to work with.



Sing couldn't have done much more in his first year. He worked his off bringing the ball out and finished just about every chance he got. He didn't have a chance in his second year.



We needed cover in the positions that Byrne played and he was the best available. Had we not brought in that cover, we'd have been short and Sharp would have been rightly castigated.



He was our best prop for two years and was much better than what we've had in his role previously. Plus he was a late signing after other options didn't come off. Had we then gone into the season a prop short with a quota space open, Sharp would, again, have been rightly criticised, especially after what happened to Carvell in our first game.



He was poor, but was no more of a gamble than Moa. One paid off, one didn't. It happens.



Rubbish. He used the available quota spots, as any coach would, and brought in the best that was available in the areas that we needed cover. Not all were ideal, and his hand was forced in a few cases, but his recruitment wasn't bad generally.

Disagree with all of that.

Well argued.

sharpe was like kear and agar, always a better assistant than head coach