I thought the commentary on the Hull game was the best I have heard in years, 1 commentator, 1 or 2 summarisors and 1 pitch side is sufficient. Remove T O'Connor, Phil Clarke and Stuart Cummins, replace Eddie and I would consider subscribing to Sky sports again.
Also thought Jodie Cunningham was ver good,
Proof that too many cooks spoil thr broth.

She was awful(a bit harsh wasn't very good though), this token female pundit on every sports broadcast , is becoming a joke. Sorry if that ain't pc, but I just don't get it

because she was good, and female, and you're stuck in the fifties?

I hate sexism, if you can do better apply, see how far you get.

Haha I'm really not, for me it is sexism against men, she's taking a job from a man who would be better suited, someone whos actually played mens super league. I hate the hole sexism bull to, funny how women don't campaign for 50/50 splits on divorces haha, im not by the way, but hear plenty of horror stories

As usual on this forum the main topic is hi-jacked and turned into a discussion on other matters.
The number of people covering commentary was what I was referring to and 3 or 4 is better than 7 or 8.
Just as a side note she was far far better than Mr O'Connor in my opinion.

Apologies, wasn’t much of a conversation to be fair, don’t mind the numbers , just wish they’d get rid of that clown ref pundit, seriously just agrees with every decision, unless it’s something blatantly obvious that even he can’t defend

What I didn’t like was when that Jodie was speaking, I kept expecting a reply from Bill Arthur. I just seemed as though she was mentioning things and no one was interested in replying she seemed to know her stuff though but I quite like Brian Carney in that role.
Bill Arthur commentating with Jon Wells and Brian Carney summarising is all that’s needed imo

so, confitmed old sexist, until you get to a nursing home and want a woman looking after you. RLFans are stuck in 1950,, along with the game, they are dying.

Haha I was born in the 70s you muppet , a little bit of common sense and less off the pc brigade and the world will be better place, calm yourself daft lad

I was born in the seventies too, but I don't judge ability on genitalia.

Rugby League fans are stuck in the past, that is why the game is dead.

I didn't think she was good couldn't hear what she was saying.

I thought the same but that isn't necessarily her fault, Sky should sort the sound out. I just thought it was a refreshing change instead of having 8 people all trying to get their opinions expressed.
Less is more in this case.

She didn't seem to have anything interesting to say.
Lets be honest, it's just Sky being p.c.
If you're going to have a female voice in the commentary box get someone who's involved in a SL club. There's plenty involved in the backroom staff and there has been for years.
Otherwise we should also have male amateur coaches as summarisers too.

Just get John Kear in, makes any game sounding exciting

tbf every sport does seem to be popping female presenters in, Now if like clare balding at racing or laura davies at the golf no problem at all but some I think really, and before you quote am anti female presenters am not, as long as there up to it,