For me taking all things into consideration I've gone for Sika Manu over Watts.

Watts has been very good when on the pitch but the amount of games missed through suspension for me have given Manu the edge. Sika Manu this season has been solid and consistent through the season with the only blot being his suspension.

It's been so close for me between these two but just felt Manu with all factors considered for me at this point has been POY out the 4 nominated.

Although quiet lately in comparison to earlier in the season I still struggle to see past Kelly
Won us several games..some with outrageous individual play. Done more of the hard stuff in D than you rarely see in a halfback and its stood out when he's missed games..oh and our top try scorer
2nd for me would Sika for sheer consistency
Watts has been sent off twice. Binned once. Banned on 3 occasions and missed 7games via bans. As damn good as he's been I can't reward that over sikas warrior like performance or Kelly's brilliance

Camp Sika for me.
Doing it tough.

I voted for Sika too. Consistently performed to a high quality this year, big plays in attack & defence.

Wattsy may have got it, but his disciplinary record is pretty poor. I reckon if he had a better record he'd be a shoe in for a World Cup spot.
Kelly has been brilliant, Shaul has had a decent year.

Mentions too to Bowden, Carlos & Connor too who have all really improved.

Really tough call tbh this year .
For me it's Watts or Sika .
Carlos T has really upped it this season too and I'd even go as far as to say he's the most under rated player in SL