He was excellent at the Storm as a very young man, I fail to see how he'd struggle with a further two years development under his belt.

Will be a massive loss to us but as has been said previously, this is the risk you run when you sign younger players from the NRL. There's always the chance they will outgrow you, best of luck to him back in Aus.

He wasn't, he showed flashes of very good play mixed in with inconsistency, poor reads in defence and a few important errors.

If he was that good Bellamy wouldn't be playing Chase Blair in the centres.

We'll agree to disagree on Fonua.

The bit about Cheyse Blair is irrelevant though, you're always going to have to balance the cap when you have Smith, Bromwich, Cronk & Slater on your roster. The fact they signed cast offs like Blair & Ryan Morgan is testimony to that. I'd hazard a guess that we were willing to pay Fonua a good chunk more than he'd have been able to command at Melbourne at the time. Much like he'll be getting offered massively improved terms if he were to return to the NRL next season. He didn't come to Hull for the sunshine.

Fox Sport in Australia saying that West Tigers had today 'finalised deals to bring both Mahe Fonua and Corey Thompson to the Tigers".

Towards his end of his time there he went from a interchange player to dropped. He hardly played in the 2nd half of the season. Storm can always find decent money for outside backs, addo Carr won't be on peanuts, so my point about Blair isn't redundant because it isn't about money. Blairs more consistent and doesn't make the poor reads and errors Fonua does. That's why he plays for Bellamy.

Fonua has been fantastic for us. He goes down as legend because he was part of the CC winning team at Wembley and I'd waited 42 years to see that having started watching FC at 18. If he goes well thanks lad because you've done very good for us. When we signed him I thought he was not good enough. Way too prone to errors but in SL Jesus been great. He will go back a better player. If he stays for this sason and goes back after we win the Grand Final well that will really top it off. Need to keep Sika. Need a good hard mongrel in the pack for next year and we will be fine. Hope Motu has got us sorted before he goes

Sika has had a good season so far.Wouldnt surprise me to see him also return to Australia at the end of the season.Big loss if he goes

manu is 30 and wasn't going well in oz before he came over here so I'd be surprised if he went back

agreed different situation to fonua

Good, unsung hero for us, hope he stays

Manu wouldn't get an NRL deal now. The weekend he was announced, he was named on the bench for Penrith so I watched the game, and he had a nightmare! So glad that he has turned out to be a real unsung hero - a better version of Adam Maher