Got to stick with the same 17 week after week barring injury or loss of form. We need to build consistency so stick with the strongest 17 for me. I thought Horney played well last week and played well in defence for the best part of the game. I'm not sure if playing Miller would disrupt the team. Discipline will be key this evening if we have any hope of a win.
(We will also need the goal kicker to have his kicking boots on)

Westerman has asked to step down from goalkicking duties so it'll be Crooksy tonight.

personally id go with rankin at fb miller and horne hb spots, start with Houghton and bring azza on later

What's Shaul done wrong?

Out of interest, why? Rankin had a very good game, so did Shaul, so why move them round?

rankin has played some of his best stuff at fb, and shaul aint a ball handler like rankin, and against a team like saints I think we could do better with extra creator on the field.
Just my opinion

shaul hasn't done anything wrong, just don't think he has the same attributes as rankin and rankin with miller and horne would give us more creating options

I reckon that's why Radford is letting Westy play that type of role at 13 rather then playing with a 3rd prop type 13. Frees Shaul up to do what he's good at without the pressure of trying to create things for others.

Westermen doesn't want to take kicks.
Westermen felt Gentle was playing him out of position.
Westermen an expensive flop (my opinion)
I see a pattern emerging.

Westerman's performance last week suggests that he was being played out if position. As for the kicking, we know he's not a brilliant kicker, and he obviously knows this too, so why shouldn't he put his hand up and say' "I'm not confident with my kicking, maybe it would be better for the team if I stepped down."

I was stating facts other than the point which I stated was my own opinion, the last point was purely speculation.

I