He didn't push him. Worst decision from a VR I can ever remember.

Didn't see anything wrong with it at all. If it was the other way around I would have probably said "he pushed him!" When watching the replay, but i wouldnt have said it very loud or convincingly.

If it was the other way round without a doubt the try would have stood

No doubt at all

Atkins reaction was the best. Went down like a footballer

Could have gone either way imo for a tv game , Non tv game ... it's a try.

Atkins full on pushed Whiting in the second half but whiting managed to get onto it, but still, should have been a penalty

Minimal contact for me.
That's a try 9 times out of 10.

This. There was contact with the hand, but Atkins was already going down and as others have said, contact was minimal. I look forward to tries being chalked off in future for similar minor infringements, but won't hold my breath

It's as if there is a directive within the RFL to stop FC being a top 4 team....disgraceful decision and the ref should be docked 2 points lol

It's as if there is a directive within the RFL to stop FC being a top 4 team....disgraceful decision and the ref should be docked 2 points lol