Ridiculous decision and thank God it was not critical

Ridiculous.

Yes.

A shoulder barge (if both players are running in the same direction) is OK, it wasn;t a shoulder barge

didnt agree with it at the time. however whiting clearly does push atkins..
rules of the game you cant do it.
shame as seeing lineham racing to the line was great stuff

He didn't push him. Worst decision from a VR I can ever remember.

Didn't see anything wrong with it at all. If it was the other way around I would have probably said "he pushed him!" When watching the replay, but i wouldnt have said it very loud or convincingly.

If it was the other way round without a doubt the try would have stood

No doubt at all

Atkins reaction was the best. Went down like a footballer

Could have gone either way imo for a tv game , Non tv game ... it's a try.

Atkins full on pushed Whiting in the second half but whiting managed to get onto it, but still, should have been a penalty