He was great for us, we all the know the history of his departure! So no need to go there, but don't say he wasn't!

Let's face it, we have 2 of the fastest wingers in the comp, yet we don't have anybody who can get the ball to them, he would, even now.

For what it's worth, I wouldn't be interested, but he's got more in his locker than we have currently, ex DJ

I'm just as frustrated as every FC fan

Im of the same feelings but what if it wasnt really Judus's fault but more of the previous owners/cheif executive?

I don't think that something that happened 6 years ago should be held against the man forever. He's had his criticism. Well... He's had more than that!

If he's good enough and available, the club shouldn't let past transgressions (which I'm pretty sure he's admitted he regrets) get in the way.

That doesn't mean I think he's good enough or available though! I wouldn't know! But I'm not willing to cut my nose off to spite my face. If there's a halfback out there that could do a better job, we'd be mad not to go for it.

We're currently is as bad a position as any time since Cooke left us. Not only would I be happy to see him here for the season, I can think of 5 other championship halfbacks I'd be happy to come and help us out. Going to watch Hull is an absolute borefest right now, and any amount of average halfbacks would be better than none.

I wouldn't have him back but at least he can construct a set of 6 unlike any of our current players in line for the halfback spot.

Well rule aint yer now to say them words "paul cooke will never play for Hull FC" while i'm in charge of Hull FC (think there uncle kaths words really )