Sin binning MUST come back !

Bottom line is offending team suffer no penalty during the match. Sending off puts too much pressure on the ref and spoils the game - 10 mins survivable.

Was that meant to be a pun on Jakes post?

agreed

also with Westerman's ban, Watts Injury, hear that O'Meley and someone else were hurt it was probably a good thing that we lost last saturday otherwise we would have got absolutely battered by Wigan

I think westermans was a bit harsh, yes it was high but it was one of those reactions that happen when someone steps at the last minute

Both Westerman and Maguire probably deserved a ban but that being said, I think Maguire's was worse than Westerman's. Maguire's was a blatant swinging arm whereas Westerman's was much more of a lazy grab. Harsh that the RFL deemed them both offences that warranted a ban of the same length but I'm glad they're pulling players up for high shots.