Good at all of the above, parts brilliant parts good....That's why he's head and shoulders above anyone else in this league and will only get better.

He's brilliant as a broken field runner and good at everything else. He's not head and shoulders above everyone else in the league. You need to stop listening to Eddie and Stevo cracking one off over him every week.

Even if he just passes the ball Eddie tries to tell us it was a "brilliant" pass. If he knocked on with the line at his mercy, they'd probably try to convince us that was world class too. Some people are gullible enough to get sucked in to all the hype, some watch the games for themselves.

Have to agree, and he is nowhere near the player Gregory, Edwards or Hanley were for Wigan.

Name 1 overall better player in the league then?

rangi chase
james roby

Listening to Eddie and Stevo about Tomkins is like going back in time and listening to the going on about Mcguire for Leeds, as soon as any young player comes on the scene that can do something a little different they are all over them!! He is a great player and may only get better, however he is still young and nobody knows how much better he will get or if this is as good as he will ever be!

IMO there's only Tomkins, Roby and probably Chase that the Aussie teams would want from S/L, Tomkins is quality, and will get better as he's still very young, It's hard to compare him to the likes of Edwards, Hanley and Gregory because they had played for so long and done so much but I reckon Tomkins will be up there with them in time.

If only he wasn't such a cheating lol.

On 120K a year at Saints according to the HDM, shocked that someone so average can be on so much, no wonder Saints are letting him talk to other clubs with a year to go...which is RL code for 'Club is willing to pay for a taxi to anywhere down the M62 to get player off the books'

There's a few that could go to NRL. Haven't Briscoe, Hall and O'Loughlin been (allegedly) approached in the past year? Also looks like Sam is going back.

Not heard the Hall or O'Loughlin one, and who came in for Briscoe? I know he wants to go next year but didn't realise any team was lined up.

Hull had a look at Shenton, until they saw that he was on 120k. They said they would look again if he would consider accepting 60k. We dont need another centre, with Arundel coming in, Crooks looks like he can make the grade at S.L level.

Finch and Kite rumours not going away yet i hear....