Quote: Robbo4 "Ok the situation is that a Hull player puts a kick in that is charged down by a Wire player. The ball falls to another Wire player is stood in front of the player that charged the ball down. He is then tackled by a Hull player. The result today was a penalty to Wire. So in what circumstances is that a penalty to Wire?
The only possible explanation I can think of is that Mr Ganson decided it wasn't a charge down and the Hull tackler was in front of the kicker and therefore didnt give the receiving (secondary) Wire player 10 meters. Would this be correct or does the first touch by the Wire player (even though not a charge down) negate the offside?'"
Surely if the Wire player who got the ball was actually in front of the Wire player who charged the ball down he was off-side