Quote: jimmyfivebellies "Based on performances over the last 18/24 months i would take Sharp over Broughton any day.'"
Far be it for me to question how many Harlequins & Salford games you have taken in over the last '18/24 months', but it's worth pointing out that, playing in what were pretty comparable sides, Broughton has outscored Sharp by 23 trys to 16 in that time period. Also, Broughton's trys to games ratio is more than twice as good as Sharp's.