hmmmmmmmmmmm whiting is never shocking,made a mistake or two, but hey so what.

Totally agree, its a sport and players are never going to play their absolute best in every game. Whitings good games far outweigh his bad.

IMO he is definitely one of our stand out players this year, along with the Ogre of course!!!!

Agree. But it's still worth pointing out that it happened and i'd hope Agar looks at our sliding defence in general. It's made Hall and now Whiting both look poor at times this season.

makes more mistakes than most defensively.shame,but true

He does. But he's also been hung out to dry and then blamed for tries that were down to our sliding defence and not him, similar to the Whiting efforts who then seems to avoid blame.