i'm glad he got his extention. but i do think the captaincy needs to go to someone else. crocker, thorman maybe?

We've got 5 better back-rowers already. Possibly more.

Hence the reason he WILL be playing prop next season

what a joke, I have no problem with Radford getting a new deal IF he had shown in the first part of next season good form, as he is a professional and committed player. But once again Hull FC hand out contracts like sweets early on in the season (even before the new season this time!!) and then wonder why we have no cap left to sign someone good in the summer.

Radford is a player in decline IMO, getting slower with each season, and we have loads of 2nd rowers anyway. A very poor signing.

IMO he should play prop next year. let crocker and tickle start with manu as an impact player.

But i can spell, and dont SHOUT !!!, shouldnt you be at school son.

Radford is the type of player that very few fans would get excited about signing, not because of who he is, but because of his style of play. When people think of what attributes a good second row forward need, most will think of speed, power and the ability to offload under pressure. Teams would become very predictable if this were how all coaches perceived the ideal second row to be.

Radford is a completely different type of second row to someone like Jon Wilkin, who people will no doubt compare him to. Radders has his flaws, and lacks speed, but he is one of the best defensive forwards in the league and it constantly takes gang tackles from the opposition defence to stop his runs. Rather than been explosive, he grinds teams down.

Wilkin or another player of his mould could have a very mediocre game, but have one burst of pace and score a try and people would leave the ground saying how brilliant he was. A Radford style player could do everything right in a game that was expected of them and take 18 hit ups off load 6 times and make 30 tackles, and a lot of people would still say that it was a poor performance.

Radders may not catch the eye, but is still far more than an average second row imo, although I would agree he may not be everyone’s cup of tea as a captain.

But you don't know how to end a question.

Or any correct punctuation.

?

He'd be fine if that is what he did week-in, week-out. He doesn't though. He continually comes up with costly errors in both attack and defence, whether it's forcing a stupid offload or giving away a needless penalty. Plus he tendency to fight for every extra yard, at the expense of a quick play, is extremely annoying and detrimental to the team. When you than factor in his lack of pace and lack of tackle-busting ability, he doesn't look like the sort of player a team aiming for silverware should have.

He's been good in the past, often very good, but he's finished now, based on the evidence of the last couple of years.