i agree, it does help if the criticism is justifed and the poster can offer more than a good slagging. but i repeat, where is the good slagging?

In Kear we trust

My god it's like platting fog with you sometimes, did you even bother to read my post. Did JK sign Tomlinson and Talipau? Did i say have blind faith in every coach who has coached us or did i say "Mr Kear has not let us down in the signing stakes when taking a chance on a player who would probably struggle to get another contract in SL"

Andy Kelly coached us into this league in the first place, and made duff signings, Shane McNally coached us to out best finish in decades, and got it wrong, yet some put John Kear's decisions above debate - not the best way to deal with things surely?

My new years resolution is not to slag the team off when

(i)they miss a tackle
(ii)fail to score on every set
(iii)fail to get a 40-20 on every kick

You started all this



5 mins into the first game you'll have "bust the resolution"

I hope I made it clear I overheard it rather than agree with it.

There are so many supporters in the stand who just whinge all the time on the stands.... it makes me support the team with positive encouragement all the more.

The audience with was a good case in point, the people I was sat with where horrors.. slagging Ted off like mad... so depressing.

Were you sat with Diane?

Quallity

Criticism is good if it is constructive, Some people on here cannot distinguish between that and a good slagging. If you comment on this then you are told its their opinion to which they're entitled to, the problem is that once you have accepted the point they automatically assume that you have conceded that their opinion is the right one and dismiss yours as being wrong.

Is this your new image(talking sense)

knew you would come round in the end

Oh before I forget Happy New Year



P.s have you found my pm address yet

6/8 weeks into the season maybe but after a xmas pi55 up game friendly with no meaning, get real man.