May be signing Howarth on loan initially is possibly in preparation for next season as a cheap utility squad member....covering 9 or 13. If so its not that contentious and probably with a view to Godinet moving to 6 hopefully than him leaving the club.

What has godinet actually ever done in 18 month?? Dont get it hes done absolutely nothing.

The problem seems to be that what have any of them done.

Godinet is class. McShane is a donkey Championship player. I am aghast how we bring Godinet on as a bit part player and start the match with that cart horse at 9. At least tonight we kepy Godinet on for the greater part of the game but for Pity's sake I don't claim to be the Ferguson of RL coaching but you would have to be blind to not see how Godinet improves us. EVEN THE SKY COMMENTARY TEAM SAW IT!

Agreed. It boggles the mind as to how some people rate McShane as one of the best hookers we've had when he is quite the opposite. Slow, lumbersome and overweight. Passes forward most of the time. Kicks out on the full most of the time. One can see why Leeds were eager to get rid.

ERRR TAKE NZ to bits in their World Cup game and look one of the most promising newcomers in the World Cup. ..then hardly get a chance to control a game cos he's used as an impact player when he's light years better than McShane???

Every time Godinet comes on the whole attack speeds up. His running from dummy half usually has defences unsure and he draws defenders. OK every now and again it doesn't work out but the same could be said of most creative players. Personally he's one player I would definitely keep.

There are very few players I would keep based on what we have seen to date.

Talk of Washbrook (Think he is OOC) coming back to Hull next season, not convinced he is what we need, how has he gone for you this year?

Been one of the better players, but that's not saying much. I'm not sure he's the standard if Hull are to make the top 8 on a regular basis.

Possibly having his best season for us. He has played a bit more in the second row and being wider out seems to have given him more impact in attack. Also covered hooker in an emergency and whilst he hasn't broken any pots doing it he has done a fill in job ok. Still gets through a mountain of work defensively, he'd be a handy pick up for you to give your squad depth.

I would expect him to be a cheap squad player, who would be used to cover injuries, a replacement and improvement on Howarth.

Been one of our best back rowers this year, that's not saying much mind. Previous three years he's been average at best.

Whats up with Craig Hall folks ? Did he pick an injury up or what ?