Would not put Amour or Murphy in the same catagory.

Amor was by far the best player for Wakefield today. Murphy was poor by his own standards today and was partly responsible for 3 of the Saints tries due to poor tackling and positioning.

I thought Amor and Korki played well. The rest were far behind.

100% agree which as I said to someone at the game is worrying given he is the only on loan player we have and appears to put more in then some of "our own" players.

Yep, far and away the best players.

Just to add some balance, JH has lost 1.5 stones since arriving, so he is at least trying,

No excuse though - he should have arrived at fighting weight, with only match fitness to achieve.

That's like throwing deckchairs off the Titanic.

Still extremely unfit though.

I did say that.

From what I heard today, his signing and subsequent selection has been extremely divisive; I blame him for turning up in a disgraceful condition, and JK for picking him in that condition.

The sad thing is that with an off-season, he could be outstanding.

Don't see it myself just another average overseas player if he was any good he would still be playing NRL

1st time i ever saw him play yesterday. Im just glad i had a free ticket so i didnt contribute to his wages. The bloke's a disgrace and jk is a disgrace for picking him

To be fair Hickey was involved with our most exciting attacking play of the first half, not hard I know but I thought he deserved some credit !

I was going to point that out, but it's not fashionable at present; his 1-2 interchange with Tommy Lee (?) just in front of their sticks was a touch of class that very nearly put us over for a try.

Yeah that was the one, nice hands. Although he did ruin it by conceeding a penalty.

What i dont understand is why he isnt losing weight, i cant see no difference in him at all. The weight should be falling off him. Its a joke.

Yeah, you would think he would have been involved in some kind of fitness boot camp. Alot of our players seemed to be unfit yesterday ! What I cant understand is why would you play him if he wasnt fit enough to make the initial squad, ok i understand higgins pulled out last minute, but why not move pj back to prop and bring spiers in as a second row (or is he injured ?).