Yeah but then you have an incident like Huby in our game, tackles from behind & then a fast ptb means he is automatically offside. Think he should be allowed to keep still if getting up would impede attacker

My comments were only about the Wakefield game.
The incident in Huddersfield was just ridiculous.

Again I'd agree with the roll away being given the benefit of the doubt but players don't do that. They roll off the player and try to get onside. That effectively impedes the attacker.
If you are beaten in the ruck you need to roll off the quickest way and if that puts you out of play that is your fault.

I think that if the player impedes the play of the ball or the dummy half being able to collect the ball then it should be a penalty for interference. I also think it should be a penalty if the ball is passed backwards into a player who is in an offside position. However if the ball is passed forward into a player then it should be a penalty against the player who has passed the ball.

(I think that makes sense)

You'd end up with about 10 penalties a game for it, just look at how many times there is a defender left in back play at the PTB, nothing to stop dummy half picking it up and passing it backwards into the man on the floor.

I think the need to distinguish between if a defender is interfering or not - if he's on the ground, not in the line of passing then he should be ok and not be able to be used as a penalty milk.

EDIT**** - RFL response

A bit late for Trinity. result still Trinity 8 Hull 12

Shouldn't the refs already know the rules about unsporting conduct and therefore do they need to be told it's unacceptable?

Sky sports just announced
Referees instructed to penalise players throwing the ball at defenders

If you knock the 2 points off that penalty it was still a win for Hull.
Let it go Idina

I thought that Ganson was in favour of the 'unsporting conduct' last week, this week he aint. No wonder we can't get consistency from referees.

Voila!

He kicked more than one penalty from a deliberate play the ball onto a defender didn't he

Yes it was twice.