So, you'd drop Walshaw to sub's bench to make way for Lyne? How does that reward him for a good game against Huddersfield?

What a ridiculous question. You know we don't reward good performances, just drop them again for our "favourites".

Sorry, I must stop thinking!

The interesting thing is the players you have not picked. It is reasonable to drop them all after recent performances
however I bet their combined wages make up quite a chunk in our wage bill and they are also some of our senior players. To me it just shows how bad things have become.

The point I was trying to make is that if we had signed good loan players in the first place we would not need to be signing anymore. Also we got it wrong once so what's to say Agar will get it right with further loanees

Walshaw should be at centre with Collis with Lynne taking Fox's place on the wing. Moore should be starting at 10 with the form he has shown. Tautai is our best loose forward IMHO and it's not coincidence that when he's played there we've competed with the like of St.Helens.

I'm hoping to see Hull line up like this.

Shaul
Talanoa
Yeaman
Crooks
Crookes
Rankin
Miller
Paea
Houghton
Carvell
Ellis
Tuson
Westerman

Feka
Bowden/Whiting
Thompson
Heremaia

A game too early for Setimata Sa to make his Hull debut unfortunately. our props are real stand outs in most games barring the KR game. Westerman been our stand out performer and is usually mom each game he plays. Jordan Thompson is having a fantastic debut season for us. Honestly can't believe just how good he is. He's loving playing in the front row, and has said he's happy to make the transition there permanent.

How ironic that none of you can agree on our best 17 and where they should play.

are you Richard Agar

If Lubey isnt selected after he did so well against Englands world cup centre it would be disgraceful, but then again RFA did it to Danny COWLING after the Saints game

Wasnt SA one of those introuble with the law over trouble in Leeds after our game against thr Dragons a couple of seasons ago. if so how as he got a Visa , Latu couldnt get one to play at Salford, allegedly.

And most say Sammut at 6 and Godinet at 7 it was working why change it.Oh dear forgot Agar had to get Seijka in somewhere instead of telling him he would have to fight to get a spot more so after the length of time he has been out of the game through injury you would at least bring him in steady away but no its bang straight in.

I have no idea why it was changed but looking on the forum the majority are now showing Sammut at full back. I presume he must have got this correct so we are left with either Sykes or Seijka to fill his stand off spot. I would personally put Mathers to full back but Agar and most of the forum disagree.

I would ask you who do you think should be at full back because to release Sammut to play stand off someone will need to play there. I know that the usual forum member will suggest Wilde a player he selects in everyone of his teams but not necessarily in the same position.