A centre who cannot/will not pass is no centre at all, i got a lot of time for him, but I wish that he would start even offloading and if he can apply himself to learning, then we could have a great player on our hands

Huge over reaction and very unfair on Atkins. Yes he should have passed a couple of times and didn't this just shows that he will never be an international centre, whatever that may mean these days (not a lot some might say unless you play for NZ or Aus), but still is a more than capable player for us. What a surprise Petersen has left and suddenly he's the dogs dangly bits and it's all Atkins fault! I always stuck up for Petersen and have never rated Atkins as much as some seem to do but to have such a turn around in opinion on these two players is typical Wakey. It was a bad day at the office, a really bad day, both teams were really poor you could pick any number of players from both teams today who, on that performance, should not be playing prfessional Rugby League and we should be grateful we only lost by 8. It's done and gone we now need to pull our socks up and produce performances like Leeds/Saints rather than the pathetic 'effort' today.

We should stick our neck out and put him in the 2nd row.

Using that logic we shouldn't comment on anything and unfair on jonh as many have made the same point.

Would you say it's right to select Grix on the wing, for example, or is Kear the only one allowed to comment?

all i can say is show us the money Leeds

He will never make it in the pack far too workshy he’s a winger end of could be a bloody good one at that

As for centres I cant name 3 good Brits in the world what a sad state of affairs we are in just the same at SH and SO

I think your deluded! Atkins struts around, he's the typical jobsworth!! If the ball don't come near him it's not his responsibility!!! He never cones looking for the ball, even murphy came looking, atkins just stood on his wing.
He's an absolute =rededit he's made players around him a scapegoat, somebody come and buy him please!!!!!!!!!

=redNot having that on here, no need.

Bigal1.

your absolutely 100% spot on, he's got all the talent in the world, my problem is that he is just lazy, never helps out in attack or defense, if you want him I will gladly drop him off, because he is doing zilch for us!!

Soz!! But he is

Pathetic comments.

No-one is questioning whether Grix is a winger though, we all know he isn't but he's covering there as we're short of numbers. For me he's done ok, probably better than any other option we couldhave had there.

Atkins has a few poor games and holds onto a ball instead of passing and all of a sudden he's not a centre, never has been and never will be. What a load of e that is.

Ryan is probably a victim of his own success, he's a danger man and will probably be picked out by opposition as a danger man. In recent times he's busted a tackle and sent wingers away on numerous occasions, one on one I'd back him to bust a tackle and get free more times than not, but he's more and more of a marked man and is struggling to bust those tackles and get a ball away.

Yesterday he backed his strength at being able to bust the tackle one on one and had he done so he may well have passed further on up the field to put someone in when the cover came across and everything would have been great. He didn't bust that tackle though, similar to Paul Wellens against us when he made the same mistake.

It baffles me that everyone is quick to identify that good English centres are a rare breed and hard to find, yet we have one who is in the top 3 or 4 in the country and because his form has dipped we want to ship him out and get rid, he's still only young and has plenty of time to work on things and become a better all round player.

why so??