If Chester did have any other players to pick from then it is a ridiculous decision to put the likes of England and Kirmond in the 19 when they have no chance of playing.

I did question the same though tbf.

1


You are literally clueless. Can guarantee if an opposition player breaks, he will charge back despite never having a prayer of winning a foot race, eg maloudi try 2 week ago, even though the game was dusted.

He's been the cornerstone of our side this year, shuffled into the halves when we've had a fair amount of injuries.

Could it not be that it just didn't work out for Macca at wakefield but he has developed immensely at Cas working with Powell since then? I know for a fact he is 1 of our most passionate players.

I really like kyle wood as a player and has improved himself to the point where he's more than an impact hooker, he's a good hooker. McShane is exceptional, effort and all.

Unfortunately you are the one that is clueless old boy, I watched him in a struggling team week in week out and he was dire, 0 effort and it showed, He just could not be bothered. I don`t think you quite got my post though. I saw Scott Moore as a better option in that team, in fact if we did not make the swap some would say there would be a chance we would be in the championship right now.

I would not want him in my team.

Where are they both now?


I also know that McShane was injured when he came to us, so had been playing damaged for you. He didn't play for us at all in 2015 despite signing in the June.

We all know what a grub Moore is off the field however it cannot be denied by anyone who understands the game that Moore is or was the better player.

Powell spotted quickly that Moore was to much of a risk and got the deal that suited him but that doesn't alter the truth.

Give over old bean.

Seriously, you honestly believe that?

Powell spotted how rank Moore was and did a deal for a player he could develop.

The proof is in the pudding.

Harsh - he's a bit chunky, but pudding?!

I can't see why this is controversial - McShane was garbage for us in large part; he clearly didn't want to be here and looked disinterested and/or frustrated most of the time. Conversely, he's been great for Cas.

It's not that difficult.

Not the sharpest tool in the box are we - read my post again.

Oh the irony!!

Saying Moore is/was a better player shows how much you understand the game.

Your reputation is well earned!!!!!

Dear god, you do realise he was twice capped for England, has McShane?

You're inability to understand true talent however wayward is quite hilarious.

My reputation is well earned and you're another notch on my belt

I very much doubt it vasty! Saints at that time had cunningham and roby as hookers! Think you will find scotty was a scrum half when he started as a 16 year old at saints.