Not so sure!

S Tomkins - Ben Jones Bishop
J Foster - McGilveray
J Tomkins - Bridge
Ratchford - Shenton
Goulding - Briscoe
Brown - McGuire
Lomax - Brough
Morley - Peacock
Roby - Robinson
Graham - Carvell
Harrison - Westwood
Farrell - Ferguson
O'Loughlin - JJB

Myler - Burrows
Sinfield - Patrick
Hock - Crabtree
Mossop - Kopczack

Peacock didnt do it for me last night, sinfield can be excused to a point for playing out of position, but jamie just doesnt look the same, injury still giving him grief maybe. cant understand why he is captain of england when jammer was like the wildbull of the pampus

Just did a team myself, if everyones fit. Few i cant decide on though.

Widdop

briscoe
shenton
atkins
cudjoe/hall

pryce/mcguire
brough

carvell
robinson
crabtree
Ellis
westwood
burgess

diskin
lynch
griffin ( 1st club )
Simon grix

I miss the roses games, there would be more patrotizm

Widdop and Brough in the halves and we have a pretty good pair of halves too.

Time for Peacock to step aside. Been lacking for a couple of years at the top level.

We are miles behind, that team were second rate Aus and Newz players who can not get in the first teams

I actually thought it was a good idea, before they binned it but like someone else said, just because it wasn't a instant fix and hit, they got rid.
If they put the effort and time and hype into it, like in the list you've done above, there's not a lot that comes close to a roses clash. I watch cricket a fair bit at Headingley and other places and you can't beat, the atmosphere at the Roses games, whatever the format of cricket, it still generates a great deal of passion and hype.

Trouble is there is none of this hatred around in schools, by the time kids leave school these days they rarely have sensed any sort of competition, we don't breed winners anymore and it's plain wrong.

It was a fairly dull game, where we were always second best, against a team of has beans, no where near qualification/selection to top level international rugby, in a sterile environment, where half of the home supporters were supporting the opposition.
To the logic of the RFL that must count as a glorious success!!!
Well done all at Red Hall, hip hip hooray, hip hip........

bring back great britain for a starters, get rid of crapnamara, put players in positions where they are supposed to be in, where not exactly suffering of a embarrasment of riches. if you put warrington up against england they'd won. i cant understand how the rfl takes the line the direct polar opposite of the common fan.

s tompkins- widdup
foster- broughton
gleeson-shenton
goulding-atkins
riley-briscoe
myler-mcguire
lomax-brough
morley-lynch
roby-robinson
graham-carvell
frodo-ellis
mossop- westwood
sinfield-burgess

prescott0crabtree
wood-huby
hock-jjb
moore-diskin

would be mine

I disagree with that I work in a primary school and we have plenty of sporting rivalry with the school's in our local area. There is a mixture of festivals which are about the taking part and competitions which are about the winning. I know this certainly continues into the high schools.

Decent squads, I chose mine on the assumption that we wouldn't get the NRL based players over for a Roses clash and I've retired a couple of players.

I think it would be a fantastic game between those two sides, would definatly watch that.

Yeah they probably wouldnt come over from the nrl which would be more of an issue for yorks than lancs t there are plenty to take there places.