Won't this just be another Morgan Smith type gamble?

There were several super league clubs after him, so not necessarily.

Having said that I dont know too much about him

Big gamble if true, Hope we not falling in to same problem this year as last ,going on a spine of old players, .Speed in the spine is important . Not just in attack, but in defence.

Other than guessing he's an offspring of Sheffield's Dean Lawford me neither. I hope he's not some puny waif though.

Yes, but what’s wrong with that. Even if we were still in SL I’d take it but in the Championship definitely. Isn’t that the point of being the wealthiest club in the league, the ability to take chances. If the lad doesn’t work out we just get another one, most likely a man out of favour NRL player who fancies a mid season move to England.

Wallo I’m with you I’m simply not used to us being a buying club, but we now are, get used to it. I reckon once the shock wears of you’ll really enjoy it

I think the most crucial part of all the interviews was that again we were last to the party to sign players so on reality having to work twice as hard to put together the squad and unearth the gem or two. Every player will not be household name that's for sure and personally don't want them to be .re Smith he was main man at fev and obviously still thought of as super league standard. I wouldn't judge any player on last year because as a team they were all over place.

I think Morgan Smith would fit nicely in this team.

Spot on. I liked Mash and wanted him to do well, but he was under funded and lacked experience, and it showed on the pitch. It's no coincidence that we got better in the last third, because so did Mash and the players he could afford. By that time Smith was a bit of a lost cause, mainly because he's a support player who had nobody to support. Not sure he is SL standard to be honest, but he's more chance of showing it at Hull than he was with us last year.

It's also worth noting that Smith was far more experienced than this lad, he wasn't that big a gamble, where is this boy definitely is. They are not the same kind of signing imho.

Of course we are buying club, see you still argue for the sake of it. You know I nearly put a disclaimer on that last post for you not to take it literally, but I hoped it wasn't needed, my error, it was

Did we pay a fee for Walmsley?

I believe so and Doyle too following the media reports

Yes I agree. I think it said at the bottom of the announcement

You two grow up and act like grown ups please. From what I gave seen we have paid a small fee for a couple of players which we have not been able to do over last few years so another big positive for me.