We are in talks with a player who left and realised that the grass isnt always greener on the other side.

Murphy?

Ferguson?

Can't see any point in Ferguson returning, we don't need him. Murphy is the more likely name and obviously offers cover in a few positions.

Agreed, we've plenty of options in the backrow. Wouldn't be unhappy to see Murphy back.

Interesting perspectives on Fergy and Murphy, Fergy has generally played for us when fit, Murphy hasn't and other than injuries probably will not next year (3rd choice full back, 3rd choice winger, no where near a game at centre - I think 6 others played centre last year, Cudjoe, Wardle, Lawrence, George, Chan, & Gilmore, Murphy has never played centre for Giants).

Murphy makes very few errors but looks to me a player that is too conservative (perhaps had the flair coached out).

Fergy can have a shocker now and then but is in my view a class above Murphy, albeit a different position. I don't know whom you are talking too but understand Giants need to shift at least one player to sign a half back (possibly Seymour whom failed a medical but was due an op).

As I say it is the different perspective that intrigues me, you all seem to have seen something in Murphy that he hasn't shown at Huddersfield

Wow what a signing 1 more prop then we are fine a big south sea islander who is mean will do the job not crap and mean like Luaki I want size and mean. I would also try and get Jodie Broughton from Salford this guy will be a good SL winger for 10 years hes top notch that kid. Then business done for me roll on next year.

He's back from Norfolk!!!

Don't suppose there's Norfolk and chance he would go back, it's been rather nice on here.

norfolks had its week its rampton next

They just missed each other if memory serves me correct, smithy was on his first sl stint the year poore joined the eels

Broughy ?