In your (and many others it would seem) opinion. For me give the bloke he chance if he does get the gig. If Agar gets us playing entertaining rugby, decent cup runs and a bash at the play offs in a hypothetical three year contract would you still be saying it was a bad decision?

I just put Agar head to head with Kear in a game of top trumps and just dont see where he actually beats him in any managerial areas. You know when you play Top Trumps and you know that certain player cant be beat on that certain area... Agar just doesnt have that oomph about him.

Im well impressed with the way the club have gone out and bought the right players, I just think we may have taken a backward step if the Agar appointment is true in the management decision. And obviously the rumours of him holding hands and skipping down Doncaster Road with Elston doesnt help that thought either !

I'm still not 100% convinced Agar will be Head Coach. I wouldn't be shocked to see him as Director of Rugby (not sure what they do though, and wasn't he offered that role at Hull?) or as assistant to a more experienced coach to be groomed for the top job.

If we wanted a Director Of Rugby role then Kear would have fitted the bill perfectly. (Shorter hours, less of a hands on role etc..). I dont think we need one as Elstons playing days will probably mean he covers that role in his CE role in the same way Ferres had a big say on certain things when he was in the CE role too.

Key word in there is think. Basically its all down to opinions and we all differ with them and rightly so. FWIW Agar wouldn;t be my prefered choice and if he does get the job I honestly don't believe it is because he played at Dewsbury with Elston and they are best buddies, I believe it will be for the right reasons. From what we've read on here (may or may not be true) Agar wasn't our first choice so maybe if he is appointed then he's the best of the rest. All I say is give whoever gets the job a chance to prove themselves, in 12 months time judge him, don't judge him now on his performance at another club under differnet management and structrures.

Agreed. Unless AG wants Elston to concentrate solely on the business side of things then I believe a DOR would be a waste of vital resources

Agreed.