When you say witch hunt I assume you mean my one comment?

Let me be clear, I like him a lot. I was one of the pro Hampshire posters when arguing about fullback. He's a great athlete. Probably one of the bestin the league in terms of footwork at the line and clearly one of the fastest.
My comments are more about the results of the contract discussions. Whoever is to blame, I think it's affected him. It's my opinion based on what I've seen.
I also have doubts about him as the starting scrum half but the way the contract negotiations have gone we will likely never find out.

I always like to judge halfbacks when the pack they’re playing behind are dominant, on the front foot, getting quick play the balls, thus giving said halfbacks time and space to do what they’re in the side to do and create things!

For months our pack wasn’t doing that.

The last three or four games our pack seems to have had much more energy and go forward...and guess what...Miller and Brough have looked far better players...HKR away especially...

Sunday was a tight game...referee’d poorly, there were slow rucks and short tens and little fluidity from either side...were Brough and Miller any worse than Williams and Leuluai? If anything I thought ours created more...

Fact is...over that ten game or so period when we were decimated through injuries, busted and playing injured forwards you could have had a 25 year old Brough at the top of his game and I think he’d have made very little difference...

He’s contracted for another year and in a full strength squad playing well can still be an asset for me but may need looking after a bit, like Saints have with Roby this year..

But Brough and Miller were the halves when we won 6 out of our first 10 putting us there...

Rocky and Reynolds played 4 games together...2 wins...26-24 at home to Leeds and 26-25 away at Huddersfeild...and two defeats 28-26 away at Cas and 30-14 away at Hull so they hardly set the world alight?

If you look back through the season and our 6 best performances in terms of points scored and margin of victory...

Hull KR (a) - Won 38-10
Hudds (h) - Won 36-10
Hull (a) - Won 32-12
Leeds (a) Won 35-18
Salford (h) Won 33-22
Wigan (h) Won 30-20

Brough and Miller were the halves in those games...which only goes to prove...they CAN play well together when the whole team does.

Some valid points and I agree with what you are saying. You could even take it a step further and say that having Johnstone out for 90% of the season has impacted our forwards in some respects. The way he wins the collision when returning the ball often getting a quick PTB which is a dream for a forward taking the next drive. You only have to look at Saints with Makinson & Grace.

Agree 1990, the quick PTB is massive, when I watch games back on Trinity tv the wife gets sick of me shouting at our players about winning the collisions and finding their feet.

I think one of our big problems is that when we got long term injuries to our two best ball carriers and surrogate forwards tupo and Johnstone we never adapted our game.

Partly due to injury but also it highlighted how ineffective some of our forwards were in actually going forward - the thing we now seem to have are forwards actually carting the ball up with strength and pace - kt green annikin and tangata have made a massive difference in that respect.

The style of play should of been changed accordingly not just carry on as though bill and TJ we're still playing

agree with that ,

Which parts regarding brough do you disagree about specifically? Are you saying brough doesn’t call the plays doesn’t defend well with aggression?
Isn’t a good field goal kicker?

Escare is nothing to do with the debate, he’s a Wigan player on loan

Yep, agree with all that. I know he'll never be everyones' cup of tea, but I was more than happy with Brough and pleasantly surprised with how he was playing until he got injured.......which leads me onto, how many of these players have looked anywhere near back to their best since they have returned from injury??? Tupou and Ashurst injured again, maybe unlucky I guess, but I think a complete overhaul of conditioning & possibly rehab needs looking at in the off season

His kicking game was no better on Sunday than recent. The controversial Marshal try came following one of many poor last tackle choices.

When you used the word "Buzzing" IMHO Escare was the only guy who I would associate with that word on Sunday. General play throughout but specifically backing up Tanginoa for the 2nd try (which I thought Miller unbelievably almost blew) and setting up BJB for last.

Miller has been much better recently, he is taking the line on and having a go.

A good scrum half should be able to overcome any weaknesses in the pack. It is only necessary to look at Salford, their pack is not the strongest but Hastings make the whole team look stronger. I regret that Brough no longer provides the same overall team improvements

I will concede that re the last tackle option that lead to the escare try
Kicking towards Hampshire and tanganoa was never on

Disagree re miller though
Thought he was excellent

Just mentioning that one incident as part of my Escare bit.